2025-2026
2025–2026: casting as Catherine in Wuthering Heights criticised over age, appearance and regional authenticity
The choice of Robbie, then in her thirties, to play Catherine Earnshaw in Emerald Fennell's adaptation of Wuthering Heights was challenged by readers because of the character's age, appearance in the novel and the cast's lack of Yorkshire authenticity.
- State of the evidence
- Documented
Sources · 2
- [1]The Guardian'It’s just a book': Wuthering Heights casting director defends choice of Margot Robbie and Jacob ElordiMediaHigh reliability
- [2]The GuardianWuthering slights: why are film-makers afraid of casting Yorkshire actors as Cathy Earnshaw?MediaHigh reliability
Last verified: 13 September 2026
